Shortly after taking office in January 2025, President Donald Trump seized control of the global economy by imposing, rescinding, and reimposing tariffs—a volatile trade policy seemingly dictated by pettiness and financial illiteracy.
Tariffs are taxes on imported goods that are paid by the importer; for the average American household, last year’s tariffs cost the equivalent of a $1,000 tax hike. And unfortunately for Trump, the Constitution confers the taxing power on Congress. In court, Trump argued that Congress delegated that authority to him under a decades-old law regulating emergency powers. But in February 2026, the Supreme Court ruled that Congress did no such thing.
Since then, the Trump administration has refunded over $115 billion in tariffs it collected before the Court’s decision—a number that represents about two-thirds of the total tariff revenue. But when the government launched its refund program in April, it limited reimbursements to “importers of record,” meaning the parties that paid the tariffs directly.
This means that the corporations that raised prices and passed the costs of the tariffs onto consumers have received millions of dollars in refunds. The regular people who functionally paid for the tariffs haven’t received a dime. And there is little evidence that corporations intend to pay consumers back.
Home Depot, for example, plans to use refunded tariff money to offset its shipping costs and the rising price of gasoline. Warby Parker announced that it will spend its tariff refund on marketing AI glasses. Other companies are simply keeping the cash: A recent ProPublica investigation revealed that corporations like Stanley Black & Decker, TJ Maxx, and Marshalls are putting their refunds toward executive bonuses.
In effect, American consumers are being ripped off twice, first by paying the illegal tariffs, and second by not being paid back. And the Supreme Court could have prevented Americans from being shortchanged in the first place. Even though the Court eventually struck the tariffs down, it did so only after leaving the tariffs in place for a year, and without indicating in its decision that consumers, not corporations, should get their money back. Put differently, Americans are still paying the price for Trump’s tariffs because the Supreme Court bungled the case.
Trump’s tariffs were quickly challenged in court, and in May 2025, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of International Trade blocked them from taking effect, concluding that the statute Trump claimed authorized his tariffs did not in fact do so. In its permanent injunction, the court explained that “if the challenged Tariff Orders are unlawful as to Plaintiffs,” then they are “unlawful as to all.” Basically, the court reasoned that there was no sense in letting the administration impose tariffs in some circumstances if the tariffs are illegal in all circumstances.
Then, in June 2025, the Supreme Court took the opposite approach to judicial relief in its decision in Trump v. CASA, the first of the Court’s two major birthright citizenship cases in recent years. In that case, Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote for the Republican majority that nationwide injunctions blocking probably illegal policies—like the injunction that was blocking Trump’s tariffs—“likely exceed the equitable authority Congress has granted to federal courts.” As a result, Barrett directed lower courts to “determine whether a narrower injunction is appropriate.” Apparently, Trump could have a little lawbreaking as a treat.
The most immediate impact of the Court’s decision in Trump v. CASA was giving Trump a backdoor way to undermine the constitutional guarantee of birthright citizenship. But it also gave him a backdoor way to implement his tariff regime. The Trump administration appealed the trade court’s decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which affirmed the lower court’s conclusion that the tariffs were unlawful but vacated the injunction anyway, noting that the trade court would “need to reconsider this holding in light of the guidance provided by the Supreme Court in CASA.”
When the Court finally decided in Learning Resources v. Trump that the president lacked the authority to impose tariffs, it still left Americans in the lurch. In his opinion for the majority, Chief Justice John Roberts said nothing about whether or how the government must return the billions of dollars it illegally collected—an oversight so obvious that Justice Brett Kavanaugh warned about it in dissent. “Some importers may have already passed on costs to consumers or others,” he wrote. “The refund process is likely to be a mess.”
The process is indeed a mess. But it is a more expensive mess for normal people, and a less expensive mess for the corporations whose interests the Supreme Court so consistently protects. The Supreme Court prolonged Americans’ financial pain, and offered no guidance as to how Americans should be compensated. And regular Americans continue to bear the costs of the Court’s poor judgment.